There will always be a demand for nicotine, says Karl Erik Lund, a researcher at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health. When the WHO warns of a negative trend among young people in its latest report, Lund believes that the organization is drawing the wrong conclusions.
Learn more about this section
Summary
Karl Erik Lund criticizes the WHO’s report on tobacco and nicotine for, in his view, issuing one-sided warnings about nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes without simultaneously highlighting the decline in cigarette smoking. He argues that nicotine products should be regulated based on their level of harm and that the goal of public health policy should be to reduce disease and mortality from smoking, not to create a nicotine-free society. Lund describes nicotine use as something that can have multiple motivations and argues that bans do not necessarily eliminate demand. Among other things, he proposes market authorization for less harmful products, risk-adjusted taxation, and clear information about the differences between products.
About the guest
Karl Erik Lund is a senior researcher in the Department of Alcohol, Drugs, and Tobacco at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health. In the interview, he explains that he has been conducting tobacco research for about forty years and has previously worked closely with the WHO, including on a book published by the WHO’s International Agency for Research on Cancer.
Key Points
- Karl Erik Lund argues that the WHO report focuses on the rise in nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes, but fails to note that cigarette smoking is declining.
- Lund believes that nicotine products should be regulated based on their level of harm and that the goal of tobacco policy should be to reduce the harm caused by smoking, not to achieve a nicotine-free society.
- Lund describes four possible motives for nicotine use: pleasure; functional purposes such as improving focus or managing stress; therapeutic use; and social and ritual contexts.
- Lund says that bans on nicotine products do not necessarily curb demand and may cause it to take other forms.
- Lund proposes market authorization for less harmful products, risk-based taxation, and better information for smokers about the differences in risk between products.
Topics in this section
WHO Report on Tobacco and Nicotine, Harm Reduction and Risk-Based Regulation, Differences Between Cigarettes, Snus, Nicotine Pouches, and E-Cigarettes, Reasons for Nicotine Use, Norwegian Regulations on Nicotine Products, Bans, Demand, and Substitution
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Karl Erik Lund's main criticism of the WHO's nicotine report?
He argues that the report warns against nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes without also highlighting the decline in cigarette smoking and the differences in the level of harm between the products.
What tobacco policy goal does Lund advocate?
He advocates reducing illness and mortality from smoking rather than striving for a nicotine-free society.
What reasons for nicotine use does Lund mention?
He mentions pleasure, functional purposes such as focus and stress management, therapeutic use, and social and ritual contexts.
Related: Nicotine, Snus, and Harm Reduction, Prevention and Longevity